Nature Markets Dialogue responds to the VCNM Consultation
11 July 2025
Following five workshops, two Ministerial roundtables, two stakeholder surveys and a consultation engaging over 180 professionals from 160 organisations, our Nature Markets Dialogue (NMD) has responded to the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero consultation on Voluntary Carbon and Nature Markets.
Our response draws heavily on the recently published
NMD Findings and Proposal paper, and in particular our proposal for a Nature Markets Governance Scheme.
We targeted our responses at consultation questions addressing insetting, high integrity governance and stacking. Our responses continually pointed to the findings and proposal derived from the findings of the Nature Markets Dialogue over the past 18 months, arguing that:
- Insetting requires strong oversight
- Assurance and standards are not enough alone
- Legal clarity is crucial
- A statutory governance framework is essential
- Stacking should be enabled, not trialled
- A robust three-level 'additionality test' would remove the need for the limiting 'investment test' that exists in the Carbon Codes
The NMD urges a holistic, legally grounded approach to market governance. Without decisive government action to establish robust, consistent, and enforceable rules, private sector engagement in UK nature markets will remain limited. Read the whole consultation response here.
We strongly welcome the publication of the Government’s Land Use Framework for England. The Framework’s focus on integration over trade-offs aligns closely with our own submission , developed with partners across farming, development, infrastructure and environmental sectors.
The Willow Review has clearly shown it’s small businesses who stand to benefit the most from investing in sustainability. The Government's response to the Review highlights the role of Broadway Initiative in supporting those small businesses to realise that opportunity.
This week’s publication of the Carbon Budget and Growth Delivery Plan and last week's launch of the Sector Transition Plans represent two parts of the same story: the UK moving from climate ambition to coordinated delivery.