PRESS RELEASE: New report finds interest in UK nature markets still high, but more rapid progress needed to ensure impact and integrity

Broadway Initiative • 30 October 2023

The Broadway Initiative today released a review of the progress towards establishing high integrity markets for nature across the UK. The State of UK Nature Markets Report 2023 found that ‘some progress’ has been made towards the goals outlined in the ground-breaking Financing Nature Recovery UK Report published in July 2022, but the most significant opportunities lie ahead.


 The State of UK Nature Markets 2023 Report is the first annual review of progress made against the Financing Nature Recovery (FNR) roadmap and recommendations published in June 2022. The FNR Report was described as reflecting an ‘emerging consensus from the farming, business, finance and environment sectors across the country as to the actions needed to support development of these markets’ In the Government’s recently published Nature Markets Framework.


The review was undertaken by the Broadway Initiative with input from experts drawn from across the environmental, business, public and land-based sectors and independently reviewed the actions taken since the publication of the FNR report.


The report highlights three important developments: the British Standards Institution’s Nature Investments Standards Programme; the Nature Markets Framework for England; and the Scottish Government’s Interim Principles for Responsible Investment in Natural Capital. However, the report also found ‘limited progress in translating strategic goals and policy ambition into specific actions to facilitate market development,’ a situation exacerbated by the recent policy uncertainty over Nutrient Neutrality, and recommends rapid action is needed on demand drivers and governance to ensure impact and integrity.


Broadway Initiative Convenor Edward Lockhart-Mummery said: “High integrity nature markets are crucial to addressing the funding gap for UK nature recovery. The UK Government aims to generate £1bn of private investment in nature every year by 2030, and our report has highlighted the structural barriers to reaching that goal. Some progress has been made, but Defra and other departments can do even more, so we are calling on the Government to make the best use possible of the upcoming consultation and review of carbon and nature markets as a vital opportunity to renew the momentum.


“COP 28 is absolutely the moment to make this happen, to reassert the UK’s role as a global leader in green finance."


The Broadway Initiative is ready to support the UK and devolved Governments in delivering the four priorities for action identified in the State of UK Nature Markets 2023:

  • Create and deliver an implementation plan for a robust governance and institutional architecture for nature markets
  • Quantify and stimulate private and public sector demand for purchased nature services
  • Build capacity among Local Authorities, regulators, and land managers of all types, to deliver nature-based projects that can attract private income and investment
  • Ensure the continued evolution of the stacking principle as a means of future-proofing the supply of land delivering multiple nature benefits




NOTES TO EDITORS


  • The Broadway Initiative is the coalition of UK trade associations working to 'mainstream' sustainability into the UK economy. Broadway works across the breadth of the business community to understand what is needed to achieve environmental and climate change objectives, then collaborates with UK governments on the frameworks required and develops plans and partnerships in the private sector to implement change.
  • For further enquiries, please contact liam@broadwayinitiative.org.uk
by Broadway Initiative 17 February 2025
The Broadway Initiative was delighted to attend the first meeting of the relaunched Net Zero Council (NZC), the central forum where Ministers, the financial community, and leaders from business and civil society can coordinate the business transition to net zero. Broadway worked hard to secure the future of the NZC, and now jointly provides the secretariat, ensuring our members are connected to the heart of the Council's activities. The Net Zero Council has a renewed emphasis on offering expert insights to shape government policies on net zero. It is dedicated to supporting the creation and implementation of sector-specific roadmaps, equipping businesses with transition planning tools, and enabling investors to identify key opportunities. Commenting on the relaunch of the Net Zero Council, Broadway Initiative Convenor Ed Lockhart said: "UK businesses need certainty, including on the transition to a clean energy future, to invest, grow, and ultimately improve living standards. By launching the Net Zero Council aligned to the clean energy mission, the government is providing a much-needed platform for the business community, financial institutions, civil society, and government to work in partnership on a shared and inclusive long-term plan. The Broadway Initiative looks forward to bringing business and environmental organisations together to make the most of this opportunity." As the Net Zero Council moves forward, Broadway remains committed to facilitating meaningful engagement between policymakers and business leaders. We will continue to advocate for the practical measures and regulatory clarity needed to accelerate the UK’s transition to a net zero economy. Read the Government's Press Release: Net Zero Council relaunched to supercharge Clean Energy Superpower Mission Read more about the Net Zero Council
by Broadway Initiative 10 February 2025
On the 6th February the Nature Markets Dialogue (NMD) hosted the first workshop of 2025. Professionals drawn from across the demand, supply and operational sides of nature markets met to continue the discussion of the critical need for robust governance. The workshop built on 12 months of effort to convene a consensus around the future for nature market development, rooted in the belief that by working together we can reach the best possible outcome. Government is engaged and listening, at a crucial moment for environmental policy development, so we were delighted so many knowledgeable individuals joined us to pool their experience and expertise. The session was characterised by both a realism that these issues have been under discussion for some time and there has been some disappointment along the way, and by a strong sense of optimism that we will eventually secure market integrity in the UK. Perhaps inspired by the ideas in the NMD Governance Paper or by the healthy turnout of professionals prepared to collaborate, 61% of attendees counted themselves as positive that our goals will be achieved. The purpose of the event was to workshop answers to the NMD Governance Consultation , which remains open to everyone until the 28th February. From the 15 questions, six were identified as being of particular interest via a pre-meeting poll. Those six were subject to rigorous discussion in smaller breakout groups, as the attendees helped shape and form each other’s responses. The true outcome of this process will be recorded in the responses to the consultation itself , but the workshop highlighted some key themes that are sure to come out in the conclusions: The need for government leadership and action The need to learn from existing good practice at home and abroad The vital importance of the government’s new Land Use Framework consultation A clear focus on nature recovery at all times The significance of data platforms and emerging technologies The results of this consultation will build towards a governance framework that the NMD will propose to government at a future Ministerial roundtable. Everyone at the Broadway Initiative is extremely grateful to all participants, and to Bruce Howard from the Ecosystems Knowledge Network who so ably facilitated the workshop.
by Broadway Initiative 23 December 2024
At a time of significant change in UK environmental policy making, the Broadway Initiative's ' Nature Markets Dialogue ' (NMD) is seeking your views on how investment in nature is governed. Your responses will help shape our approach to Government, as we plan to propose a governance framework for high integrity nature markets. To that end, you are invited to share feedback on the latest consultation paper: Towards a governance framework for high integrity nature markets. The consultation paper has been informed by the feedback, roundtables and online workshops that NMD participants have supported over the past 12 months. A key message from the Dialogue to date is that well-designed and governed nature markets are first and foremost about providing an efficient mechanism for the delivery of verified improvements to the natural environment. Nature markets can deliver improvements to meet voluntary or regulated obligations, provide insets for supply chains and offsetting for development, and efficiently deliver government investment in nature. This is a vital moment for environmental policy development: the Environmental Improvement Plan is under review and revision; the Cunliffe Commission and the Planning Reform Working Paper on Development and Nature Recovery are seeking evidence; and we expect the Government will soon consult on the governance of Voluntary Carbon and Nature Markets. We have a unique opportunity to highlight the need for a robust UK governance mechanism that ensures UK nature markets are high integrity and make a significant contribution to nature’s recovery. We have created an online portal to obtain your feedback and views here, where we have 15 specific questions on which we would value your thoughts . In addition, we will be hosting a series of workshops in the coming weeks to progress the Dialogue around the issues raised in the paper. The process will culminate in a roundtable to present the results and recommendations to Ministers. Find out more about the UK Nature Markets Dialogue .
Share by: